How each one works

A resistive touch screen has a flexible top film over a glass layer. A press pushes the two together and the controller reads where they met. Anything that presses registers: a bare finger, a thick rubber glove, a pen, a wet hand. Water lying on the film does nothing unless it presses, which is why resistive has been the washdown standard for so long. It reads one touch at a time.

A projected capacitive (PCAP) touch screen senses the small change in electrical charge a finger makes through a glass front. It needs no pressure, reads several fingers at once for pinch and zoom, and keeps the hard, clear surface of glass. Because it senses charge rather than pressure, a thick insulating glove or a film of water can confuse it unless the controller is tuned for them. On STX Technology products both types are rated for over 100 million touches.

Side by side

Resistive (-RT)Projected capacitive, PCAP (-PT)
Thick or insulated glovesWorks: it reads pressureMay not register unless the controller is tuned for gloves
Thin nitrile or latex glovesWorksUsually works
Water drops on the screenIgnored unless they pressCan cause false touches; needs water-rejection tuning
Running water or hose sprayA strong jet can press the filmCan cause false touches; lock the screen while washing
Front surfacePlastic film: can scratchGlass: hard and scratch resistant
Cleaning chemicalsCheck the film against your chemicalsGlass tolerates most cleaners
Multi-touch (pinch, zoom)Single touchYes
ClaritySlightly duller through the filmClear
Protective membraneReplaceable sacrificial membrane optionReplaceable sacrificial membrane option

Typical behavior. Results depend on the controller, its tuning and the glove; test with the gloves your staff really wear.

Gloves

If operators wear heavy rubber, cut-resistant or insulated gloves, resistive is the safe choice: it reads the press, not the finger. A frozen-hands glove in a chiller, a chain-mail glove on a boning line and a thick gauntlet at a dip tank all press a resistive film the same way a finger does, and the operator never has to take a glove off to acknowledge an alarm.

PCAP can work through thin gloves, and many controllers have a glove setting that raises the sensitivity. The trade is that a more sensitive screen is also more open to false touches from water and knuckles. Test with the gloves your staff really wear at the end of a shift, wet and dirty, not a clean pair from the box, and test the screen in the position it will be mounted, because reach and angle change how firmly people press.

Water and washdown

Water conducts, so a film of water on a PCAP screen can look like a finger. Water-rejection tuning in the controller handles drops and splashes well; a running stream from a hose is harder, and a screen that is being foamed and rinsed may register touches it should not. A resistive film ignores water that is not pressing, but a strong jet held close can press it, so neither type should be live during washdown.

Whatever the type, give the screen a cleaning mode or a lock so a hose cannot press buttons while the line is being washed, and design the HMI so no single touch can start a machine. The IP rating of the enclosure is a separate question from the touch type: both are offered on the same IP66 equivalent enclosure, and the IP ratings guide covers what the enclosure and connectors are rated for.

Cleaning chemicals

Caustic, chlorinated and acid cleaners are hard on plastics. Glass resists most of them, which is why PCAP is the easier choice for a line that is foamed every shift. A resistive film, or the protective membrane over either type, should be checked against the chemicals and the strengths your cleaning crew actually uses, not the ones on the plan.

Ask your chemical supplier for the product data sheets and compare them with the screen maker before you order. Scrubbing pads and scrapers wear any surface faster than the chemical does, and a knife tip does more damage than a week of foam. Where knives, hooks or metal probes are used near the screen, STX Technology offers a replaceable sacrificial membrane over either touch type: it takes the wear and is changed when it is worn, and the screen beneath is untouched.

What STX Technology offers

Every STX Technology range is offered with a resistive touch screen (model codes ending -RT) or a projected capacitive touch screen (model codes ending -PT), on the panel PC, the touch monitor and the KVM monitor. A few sizes limit the choice: the 8.4" is resistive only, and the 27" is PCAP or no touch (-NT). The range page lists each size's options and writes the model code as you choose.

The optional sacrificial membrane protects the touch screen from abrasives, knives and other sharp objects and is replaced when worn. Both touch types are rated for over 100 million touches. The touch monitor and KVM monitor connect their touch over USB as standard, or RS232 serial as an option, so an existing computer with no USB port can still drive the screen.

STX Technology test results

The glove types and water conditions each touch type has been tested with: to confirm with STX Technology.

Quick answers

Our staff wear thick gloves and we hose down daily. Which one?

Resistive (-RT). It reads the press of any glove and ignores water that is not pressing. Add a screen lock for washdown and, where knives are used, the sacrificial membrane.

We want pinch and zoom on drawings, and staff wear thin nitrile gloves.

PCAP (-PT), tested with your gloves and tuned for water rejection. The glass front also takes caustic cleaners better than a resistive film.

Knives and scrapers are used near the screen.

Either type with the replaceable sacrificial membrane. It takes the damage and is changed when worn; the screen beneath is untouched.

Can I change the touch type later?

No. The touch screen is part of the front assembly, so choose it with the size. The same range offers both, and the model code records which was fitted. @related Washdown and waterproof=/env-washdown ;; What the IP ratings mean on the line=/guide/ip-ratings ;; Food processing=/ind-food ;; Meat processing=/ind-meat ;; Glossary=/glossary